When We Find Rot During Siding Replacement
Why we can’t just cover it up
One of the most common surprises in a siding replacement happens after the old siding comes off. Years of small leaks around windows, doors, roof lines and deck ledgers can quietly soak into the sheathing and framing behind your walls. From the outside, everything may have looked fine. Once the wall is opened up, we sometimes find soft, dark, crumbling wood that has been rotting for years.
When that happens, we stop and repair it before any new siding goes on. It is tempting to want to keep the project moving and close the wall back up, but installing new James Hardie siding over rotted wood would put your home, your investment and your warranty at risk.
What James Hardie requires
James Hardie fiber cement siding is a durable, long-lasting product, but it is only as good as the wall it is attached to. Hardie’s written installation instructions set clear expectations for the surface behind the siding:
- The wall has to be sound and flat. Hardie’s instructions note that irregularities in the framing and sheathing can mirror through the finished siding, and that they must be corrected before the siding is installed. Rotted or swollen wood creates exactly those kinds of dips, bulges and soft spots.
- The fasteners need solid wood to hold. Hardie siding is nailed into framing, or into rated sheathing of at least 7/16-inch thickness where that is allowed. Nails driven into rotted wood cannot hold the way they are designed to, which can lead to loose boards, cracked planks and siding that fails in high winds.
- A proper water-resistive barrier and flashing are required. Hardie requires a water-resistive barrier installed with flashing at penetrations and junctions per local code, and states that it assumes no responsibility for water infiltration. In other words, keeping water out of the wall is the job of the wall system and the installer, not the siding alone.
How this affects your warranty
James Hardie’s product warranty requires the siding to be installed according to its printed installation instructions. The warranty also specifically excludes damage resulting from improper installation, from water infiltration, from improper design or construction of the underlying wall assembly, and from movement of the materials the siding is attached to.
Put simply: if new Hardie siding is installed over known rot, and that rot leads to problems later, those problems would not be covered. Repairing the damage now protects your eligibility for the manufacturer’s warranty and our workmanship guarantee.
Why rot doesn’t stop on its own
Rot is caused by moisture that the wood cannot dry out from. Covering it with new siding does not stop it. In many cases it makes it worse, because the damaged area is now sealed behind a new layer with the original water problem still in place. Left alone, rot can spread into studs, sill plates, rim joists and window framing, attract carpenter ants and other pests, and lead to mold inside the wall cavity. What might be a few sheets of sheathing today can become a structural repair in a few years.
What happens when we find rot on your project
- We stop and document it. We photograph the damaged areas so you can see exactly what we found, even if you are not home.
- We walk you through it. We explain how far the damage goes, what likely caused it, and what needs to be replaced.
- We provide a written change order. Before any additional work begins, you will receive the scope and cost of the repair to approve.
- We fix the cause, not just the symptom. We remove the damaged sheathing and framing, replace it with new material, and correct the water source, whether that is missing flashing, a failed window seal or a deck ledger that was never properly protected.
- We rebuild the weather protection. New water-resistive barrier and flashing go on per James Hardie’s requirements and local code.
- Then the new siding goes on, over a solid, dry, flat wall that is ready to perform for decades.
The bottom line
Nobody likes an unexpected addition to their project, but finding rot during a siding replacement is actually the best time to find it. The wall is already open, the repair is far less expensive than it will be later, and your new James Hardie siding gets the solid foundation it needs to look good, perform well and stay protected under warranty.
If you have questions about anything we find on your home, just ask. We would always rather show you than surprise you.
Sources: James Hardie installation instructions for HardiePlank lap siding and HardiePanel vertical siding; James Hardie limited product warranties. Current versions are available at jameshardie.com and jameshardiepros.com.